| |
Keep The Dell Free
Our primary objection is very simple. The Dell is currently
completely free and open to all. If this project goes ahead as planned,
then it will not be. It is
currently suggested that the price of admission to Jumps course
will be £20 for adults and £15 for children per session.
We would also raise issue with many of the claims made by the organisers
of this project:
| They Claim |
The Dell is a little known area
of secluded woodland in central Hitchin. |
| We Claim |
The Dell is a very well known
and loved by the large number of people who use it.
More importantly, even if a piece of public land is not well
known, that is no justification for fencing it off and making
people pay a large fee to use it.
The solution to the problem of people not knowing about a
beautiful local resource, is to tell them about it, not to
fence it off, and build on it.
|
| They Claim |
An opportunity for families to combine
healthy aerial adventure with a day out at the shops |
| We Claim |
It will be an opportunity for
families who can afford £70 a session (assuming 2 adults
and 2 children - otherwise £20 per adult and £15
per child). Those who prefer not to pay such fees, will be
losing a beautiful free piece of public land.
Young Guys and Gals, before you offer support for this project,
see if your parents are going to be willing to pay, and how
often. If you're expecting a youth club to pay, again, check
how often they will.
|
| They Claim |
It will reduce anti-social behavior
in that area of Hitchin |
| We Claim |
The woods surrounding The Dell
are ten to twenty times the size of The Dell itself. Any anti-social
behavior will simply move 'next door'.
|
| They Claim |
People are currently afraid to go
into The Dell |
| We Claim |
It's perfectly natural, and
possibly even human nature, to be afraid of wooded areas where
you cannot see around every corner, especially in the dark.
Having spent many an evening in the dell, I'd say that I've
seen much more trouble in the street outside any pub or nightclub.
During the day, The Dell is as safe as any woods. At night,
it is as safe as any dark secluded area. If you're afraid
of such areas, then of course, don't go during the times you
are afraid, or go in with friends, but please don't ruin them
for those people who currently enjoy them.
Incidentally, the Dell is one of the few places in Hitchin
where it is possible to get a good view of the stars at night
without being surrounded by street lights. The Jump planning
application suggests it will have a 'night light' dependant
on a bat survey. We're not quite sure what a 'night light'
is, but are guessing it's not one of the things you plug into
the wall to help your kids sleep.
The light will need to be powerful enough to light up the
course from it's position next to the proposed security camera
on the fence.
Current research leads us to believe that any high powered
lighting will probably effect the bat population, which are
a protected species.
According to Gareth Jones, biological sciences professor
at Bristol University bats “have a hard wired aversion
to light.” Gareth Jones is quoted in an article in the
Guardian newspaper (thu 18 June 2009 “street lights
a threat to bats, study finds, the full study is published
in Current Biology on the same day.) “This study shows
that light pollution may force bats to use sub optimal flight
routes and potentially causes isolation of preferred foraging
sites, and therefore must be considered when developing conservation
policy.
As all species of bats in this country are given the protection
of law (as a protected species) it is illegal to do anything
to harm them or their nesting sites. Anyone can stand in the
dell and watch the bats coming to life for an evenings flying
and fly eating- a beautiful and PROTECTED sight.
|
| They Claim |
increased self-esteem |
| We Claim |
then why are they playing on
the fact that people are afraid of The Dell?
We do accept that projects like this can increase self esteem.
We just really don't like them playing on your fear.
|
| They Claim |
JUMP will offer great fun for families,
friends, schools, businesses, youth and community organisations,
stag and hen parties. |
| We Claim |
Absolutely. At least, those that
can afford it.
Youth groups, and other organisations will be able to apply
for funding, but how often?
If you ask a child if they think this is a good thing, they
will more often than not agree. That it is, until you explain
that they can only use it once a year (figures pulled from
thin air, we don't know how often councils will be willing
to provide funding for such ventures, but we think that currently,
neither do you - if you want to support this project, because
you think you'll get to use it for free, we suggest you find
out).
To only allow access once a year, while the rest of the time
it is necessary to fund it by selling it for use for corporate
team building courses, or hen and stag parties, is not the
community project this idea is currently being sold as.
It's certainly not worth losing one of the most beautiful
natural areas of Hitchin for.
|
| They Claim |
The Dell suffers immensely from
litter, and they can solve that problem |
| We Claim |
The cost of this project is estimated
to be in hundreds of thousands of pounds, much/most of which
is coming from public funding. For a fraction of that budget,
we could pay someone to clear it up. The Dell is public land
maintained by North Herts District Council. If you really
want it tidy, ask the council to ensure they maintain it.
Every now and then, we go down there and clear it up ourselves,
although we accept it still ends up being untidy again given
time.
However, even if Jump are cleaning up the litter that arrives
during the day time, they will be locking the area at night,
and all of the litter that used to turn up at night, will
just end up in the surrounding woods, or on Windmill Hill,
or wherever those people choose to hang out instead.
Again, the solution to this problem, is to sort out the litter,
Not to fence the entire area off.
Personally, we prefer the idea that we have free access to
somewhere beautiful and occasionally untidy, to a 130m long
2.4m high fence running around the entire base of The Dell.
|
| They Claim |
"the surroundings give it a
"cut-off feel" which is conducive to group activities
/ bonding" |
| We Claim |
children will happily play on
it where ever it is.
It might be nice if it is in a secluded area, but it's not
essential. If you really want children to experience being
high up in a secluded area, develop the project in any of
the woodland areas of North Hertfordshire, where they really
will experience a small piece of wilderness.
If Youth Clubs are applying for funding to use such facilities,
then take the children to a facility that is in proper woodland,
so the children get a feeling of 'really being outdoors'.
There are numerous projects throughout the country that cater
for this.
By developing this project in the Dell, this project would
be preventing the rest of us from experiencing that secluded
area during our general day to day lives.
|
| They Claim |
The Dell will continue to be free
to all users and only participants using the ropes course will
need to pay, |
| We Claim |
We accept this and we are not
stating that users will have to pay for the third/quarter
of the base of The Dell Jump intend to leave available to
us. Our point is that Jump intend to fence off the entire
base of The Dell. If people then want to use the base of The
Dell, they will be surrounded by this fence, and Jump are
charging people if they want to use the two/thirds to three
quarters which they will be taking over. Jump will be fencing
off the entire base of The Dell
You won't be able to sit in the remaining third/quarter and
ignore Jump. |
| They Claim |
the gates to the fence will only
be closed at night time allowing access to users in the day
time |
| We Claim |
We question what happens at times
when Jump are not there to open the gates, or are they going
to do this 365 days a year, but also ask why Jump have no
regard for those people who choose to use this area at night?
We also would re-iterate the previous point, you might be
able to get inside the fence in the day time, but you'll only
have access to a tiny section of the base of the dell. The
rest will be monopolised by Jumps course. |
| They Claim |
More people will use The Dell if
they build there. |
| We Claim |
More people will use The Dell
if you relocate the council tip there.
It's no justification for fencing off and spoiling such a
beautiful place. The Dell is unique in character. There are
lots of places you could build such a project, and only one
dell in Hitchin town centre. |
But forgetting all of those objections, our main
one is still that The Dell is currently completely free
and open to all. If this project goes ahead as planned, then
it will not be.
We want to re-iterate we do believe that this is a worthwhile project.
We just don't believe it is worth losing The Dell we love for.
So the big question is, how do we make this
happen, but make it happen somewhere else, or so that it does not
destroy the current charm of The Dell.
|
|